| Presbyter | Tenure |
|---|---|
| Rev. O.A. Finch | 1930 – 1932 |
| Rev. W.T. Williams | 1932 – 1946 |
| Rev. Same Singh (first Indian presbyter) | 1946 – 1951 |
| Rev. J.H. Paul | 1951 – 1955 |
| Rev. T. Ghasi | 1955 – 1956 |
| Rev. J.H. Paul | 1956 – 1960 |
| Rev. Moti Lal | 1960 – 1966 |
| Rev. P.J. Santram | 1966 – 1967 |
| Rev. A.M. Dalaya | 1967 – 1971 |
| Rev. A. Thakur Dass | 1971 – 1972 |
| Rev. G.M.A. Bhatti | 1972 – 1975 |
| Rev. S.L. Nath | 1975 – 1976 |
| Rev. George Lazar | 1976 – 1977 |
| Rev. J.H. Paul | 1977 – 1981 |
| Rev. G.M.A. Bhatti | 1981 – 1984 |
| Rev. J.H. Paul | 1984 – 1988 |
| Rev. Dr. Bruce Nicholls | 1988 – 1991 |
| Rev. Raj Murch | 1991 – 1993 |
| Rev. Baldev Sandhu | 1993 – 1994 |
| Rev. Joy Halder | 1994 – 1995 |
| Rev. Sunil Singh | 1995 – 2007 |
| Rev. Prabhakar Malhan | 2007 – 2008 |
| Rev. Samuel Ashish Jacob | 2008 – 2011 |
| Rev. Sunil Ghazan | 2011 – 2018 |
| Rev. Daman Derick Rodgers | 2018 – 2024 |
| Rev. Prateek Pillai | 2024 onwards |